2009-03-23

The iSlice­




Concept: 3 out of 5
Execution: 4 out of 5
Yeah, but: It works as advertised, and that makes me suspicious


The Long Version: Another Christmas gift that, much like the previously reviewed Open It! household multi-tool, actually works and is worth the price.
I know, I was surprised, too.

But this little gadget really does slice open envelopes and all types of consumer packaging, with no danger of drawing blood.
Perfect for the clumsy people on your gift list.
It's ceramic blade is as sharp as an ExActo knife, but for some reason won't cut skin. I suppose if you really tried you might manage some damage but in my casual testing it's been safe.

The iSlice retails around here for $5US and I have to think that's a fair price.
Especially since the designers went the extra mile and made it harder to lose in a drawer by making the metal point magnetic.
Although shown stuck to our refrigerator (with the crooked logo and Liberace) I keep mine stuck to my desk lamp for instant grab & slice action.

The name bothers me because it's yet another example of the mindless marketing people that ape the latest craze--in this case iPods.
I'm surprised there isn't a toilet tissue called iWipe.
A few years ago everything was Mywhatever due to the MySpace phenomenon.
And in the USA, every political scandal gets the word gate tacked-on the end after the infamous Watergate break-ins of the 1970s.
Travelgate?
Noooo, 'gate' was part of the name of the Watergate hotel, not a suffix that means scandal.
Journalists are a big disappointment because it appears they don't think for themselves. Failed ad copy writers perhaps?

But I digress.

The iSlice works, makes a nice little gift, and is worth the price.
It uses modern ceramic blade technology so supposedly the edge won't get dull.
Today I used it to slice open the plastic wrap on a roll of paper towels and it did the job without cutting into the product, which was a pleasant surprise.
With envelopes I have managed to cut through the first layer of paper inside, but then I don't get much mail and use a switchblade as a letter opener anyway.

I would probably never buy something like this for myself, but having received it as a gift find that I use it often and am impressed every time.

2009-03-20

Seiko Automatic Diver SKX781




Concept: 3 out of 5
Execution: 3 out of 5
Yeah, but: The Orange Monster deserves its reputation.


The Long Version: This is a tough watch for me to review: it's a really nice watch, and compares very well to ones that cost twice as much from brands like Tissot and Tag. But I hardly ever wear it, and I'm gonna tell you why.


First of all, the Orange Monster is a watch that competes well above its price-point. The colour, while not to everyone's taste, suits the watch and is very well chosen. Orange is tough to get right, and the designers did a good job. Seiko also has a great pedigree as a watch company; they've been making watches for longer than many Swiss brands, and are one of only two companies that can build a watch movement - quartz or mechanical - without buying parts from someone else. Their R&D puts them in the top ranks, with their Spring Drive being as important as the co-axial escapement and mechanically superior. And their high-end mechanical watches, rarely seen in North America, are worthy of great respect.


The problem for my particular Orange Monster is that it's still essentially an entry-level mechanical watch, and I also own a pair of mechanical Omega Seamasters (reviewed). It sucks being the adopted younger brother to an exceptional sailor and a secret agent. Sure, as a responsible parent I can try to love them all equally, but the Seiko Diver is just outclassed and there's nothing it can do about it. It doesn't have the fit and finish, it doesn't have the looks, and it doesn't have the reassuring weight or perfect balance of its bigger brothers.


I never expected the Orange Monster to replace my Omegas, and I knew that it was never going to be a watch for daily wear. Part of its appeal to me is as a collector; a Seiko mechanical is just something that I really want to own. Another part of the appeal is that looks absolutely nothing like anything Swatch Group makes. That's a much bigger accomplishment than it seems - and I should know, since they were my employers when I bought it. Everyone in the office could immediately spot that it was from outside of the family, including the many who had only passing familiarity with the Group's products. In a world where even bad designs are duplicated, and every other watch costing under $300 can pass for a Rolex, Seiko's accomplishment in finding a unique look that isn't seriously ugly is major.



The orange monster from the side. I have no idea where the red came from.


My favourite design features are the orange dial and hands. The face is bold and immediately legible, so it does exactly what I want a watch to do, although the luminosity isn't as bright or enduring as my Seamasters. The crown being offset from the 3 position does reduce its tendency to snag or bruise, and the bezel and case design contribute to the aggressive styling of the watch. The case is tall enough that it's best worn with short sleeves: it isn't called a monster for nothing. 


The most significant problem that I have is one that probably won't matter to most people, but it's critical for me. The Orange Monster is a mechanical watch. Its power reserve, while good, isn't enough to run for the 34 or so hours that a watch sits through when it's worn every other day. It can't be manually wound, so it can't be 'topped up' in the evenings. So even when I am in the mood to wear it, the Seiko doesn't want to play. It also has a day-date display, so when it does stop and sit for a day or two, it's a real hassle to get it set again. 


If the Orange Monster was my daily wear, none of this would matter. But the extra effort of wearing it in rotation - repeatedly getting it set and keeping it running - is too much like work, and the watch isn't one that I'm going to completely stop wearing my Seamasters for. I do occasionally put it on, and maybe use it for a few days or a week, but then it goes back into its place beside the Swatches in my watch box. But, befitting its status and pedigree, it does earn the prestigious middle compartment.




2009-03-13

The Photograph: Composition and Color Design, by Harald Mante





Concept: 4 out of 5
Execution: 1 out of 5
Yeah, but: It was going to get repeated readings anyway.


The Long Version: The unassumingly titled book "The Photograph" by Harald Mante is undoubtedly the most significant book on photographic composition I have ever read. (handy link to Amazon.com.) Its subtitle "Composition and Color Design" gives the theme of the book, which looks at the photograph without any reference to the subject matter. This is purely a book of design, something of a cross between the approaches of Freeman Patterson and The Tao of Photography, but with a more analytical eye. The photographs, all taken by the author, have the highest "I wish I had taken that" factor of any collection that I have seen. Other people may be less impressed, or less receptive to this compositional guide, but for me it's been a revelation.


The chapters of the book are The Point, The Line, The Shape, Universal Contrasts, Color Contrasts, and Using The Tools. In this case The Tools include things like selective focus and vertical picture formats - most books would take this as an opportunity to explain what a camera is and when to use the pop-up flash. While I wouldn't want to discourage anyone from looking into this book, it's going to be most relevant for those who already have a pretty good idea of what they're doing.


Originally published in German as "Das Foto: Bildaufbau und Farberdesign" in 2007, the English version's publication in 2008 must have rushed the process. I can't say that I have any complaints with the translation, but my sympathies go out to the person who did it. The language and concepts can be quite dense. I have far less compassion for the person or committee responsible for the book layout, and can only hope that they had the format forced upon them from the original work. Quite frankly, the layout and typesetting is a major impediment to understanding and appreciating the content.




The format of the book is to have photos on the top half of each page, with four columns below that will hold a mix of body text, notes, diagrams and additional photographs. There's no particular order, except that the body text is most likely to occupy the edge columns and photos and diagrams will be placed in the middle, but even that isn't particularly consistent. Text is set left-justified in a 31-character line, which is difficult to read and ugly to look at. Here's the first column from page 36, under the heading "Loose and Tight Groups of Points", but without the full effect of an adjoining column of text:


A large number of points (very
small shapes, which have a
point character in relation to
the surface area) amassed near
each other or together can form
larger visual points, often with
the effect of being textured
surfaces. In a loose accumulation
of points, each point stands
individually in a surrounding
field, and visual relations with
nearby points develop. Short
visual lines and/or small visual
shapes form. Bunching the
points, however, so closely that
they touch each other visually
or materially, changes a loose
accumulation of points into a
larger point — often with the
character of a small textured
surface. Photo 5 of tourists in
Florence shows in an exemplary
fashion the development of a
tightly compressed structure
from a loose cluster of points.


Really grokking the text is hard enough without the extra challenge from the formatting.


Align Center


Here's an image of pages 108-109. The columns of content of the lower half of the pages are: body text, body text, notes on the diagrams, diagrams / body text, blank, photograph, body text. In this randomly-chosen two-page spread, the text jumps across half the page twice, and once skips a column for absolutely no reason. The images on the page don't particularly line up with the text - it's common to have to flip pages to see the photos that are being discussed - so the only purpose to leaving blank space in the middle of a sentence must be to make the text physically run for the number of pages that the photos in the chapter require.




There's a lot to read in The Photograph, and it's a book that must be read with it lying flat. Be ready to flip pages and take time with it, both because the photos being discussed will span the chapter, and because it's very easy to lose the thread of the information. The photos that are included in each chapter aren't particularly tied to the text on the page; the spread above is pages 98-99, and includes photos #12-19. The text shown here mentions - in order - photos 1, 5, 6, 11, 2, 5, 3, 14, 15, 5, 2, 9, 19, 7, 8, 4, 16, 17, 18, and 13. This is the last page in the chapter, which is why it never refers to photos beyond this page - otherwise the photos would be even less synchronized with the text. Pages 108-109, which is the middle of a chapter, shows photos #6-12 and diagrams G, H, and I, and references A, B, C, B, A, C, 1, D, E, 2, 6, 14, 15, F, 5, 9-11, 18, 4, 16, 8, 19, 17, 8, 11, 7, 3, 4, 13, J, K. So while other books that study photographs, like The Nature of Photographs (reviewed) will tell you what to look at as a caption or text directly associated with a single image, Mante's book is more like walking through a gallery with all of these photos while the wise and insightful artist discusses what he sees in them all. Except that, unlike a gallery, the photos aren't all visible at once.

It's almost worth deciding to go over each chapter twice: once for the text, to get an idea of the theory in one reasonably-consistent pass, and again to look at the photos that illustrate the points being discussed.




The point of all of this nagging and pettiness is that this book fails in many ways. It's a very advanced book that deals with fundamental concepts, and so it requires careful and thoughtful reading. Make no mistake: I think that this book is worth the effort, and am slowly working my way through it fully knowing that I'll start reading it again as soon as I finish it. The reproduction quality is very good, the photos are useful and I find many of them inspiring. If I lost this copy, I'd buy another; if they release a second edition with better formatting, I'll buy it too.


I've written elsewhere that there is a lot of similarity between the photographer and the typographer, and I'll expand that here to include the layout and typesetter's art. Like the photographer, they add to the message and provide the interpretation, but their role should be transparent. When a technical fault or poor choice reduces their ability to communicate, or becomes problematic for the viewer, they have failed.


That a book dealing solely with the photograph from a design perspective should fall down so badly in its own design is an irony that even I don't find very entertaining.




contact me...

You can click here for Matthew's e-mail address.